
What Next for Energy East and the NEB?
By Bruce McIvor
Yesterday’s collapse of the National Energy Board’s Energy East pipeline review was long overdue.
From most Indigenous Peoples’ perspective, the NEB pipeline review process (including Enbridge, Kinder Morgan and Energy East) has always represented the worst of all worlds: a fundamentally flawed process leading to a foregone conclusion.
Now is the time for a fresh start. Tweaking the NEB review process is not acceptable.The reason behind the Energy East NEB panel’s resignation underscores the NEB’s inability to play a central role in fulfilling the Crown’s constitutional obligations to Indigenous Peoples.
The NEB’s Energy East panel was brought down because it engaged directly with company representatives outside of the public process. This created an apprehension of bias and a lack of impartiality.But direct engagement between government representatives and Indigenous People is precisely what is required to fulfil the duty to consult and accommodate.
Making formal, court-like presentations and tendering evidence in public to a panel of silent suits is not consultation.
Consultation is iterative. It requires a dialogue. A process that denies these elements is beyond flawed—it is invidious. It creates resentment, distrust and frustration. It undermines and mocks the honour of the Crown.The federal government must stop hiding behind the NEB and directly engage with Indigenous Peoples.
Bruce McIvor, lawyer and historian, is principal of First Peoples Law Corporation. Download Bruce's bio.
For more First Peoples Law comments see our publications page
Follow us on @firstpeopleslaw
Receive email notification of new blog postings
Download a free copy of the newest edition of Bruce's essays--order a paperback copy.
All-Time Most Popular Posts
The Age of Recognition: The Significance of the Tsilhqot'in Decision
The Case for Denying Indigenous Rights
Provinces Burdened with Responsibility for Fulfilling Treaty Promises
What Tsilhqot’in and Grassy Narrows Mean for Treaty First Nations
Environmental Assessments and the Duty to Consult
The Piecemeal Infringement of Treaty Rights